What are the pros of The Wolf Among Us?

Exceptional world-building and writing that successfully translates fairy tale lore into a hard-boiled detective story.. Strong character development and high-quality voice acting that create a compelling, mature atmosphere.. Distinctive and stylish comic-book-inspired art direction that remains visually impressive years after release.. Engaging mystery plot that maintains tension and interest across its episodic structure..

What are the cons of The Wolf Among Us?

The 'illusion of choice' is easily dispelled on repeat playthroughs, as many decisions lead to the same outcomes.. The game is relatively short, with some players completing the entire story in under 10 hours.. The ending can feel rushed or leave certain narrative threads unsatisfactorily resolved.. Technical glitches occasionally interfere with critical dialogue choices or gameplay sequences..

The Wolf Among Us

From the makers of the 2012 Game of the Year: The Walking Dead, comes a thriller based on the award-winning Fables comic books. As Bigby Wolf you will discover that a brutal, bloody murder is just a taste of things to come in a game series where your every decision can have enormous consequences.

98%

Overwhelmingly Positive

DeveloperTelltale

PublisherTelltale

Release DateOct 11, 2013

$14.99

Peak Players14.1K

Metacritic85

Controllerfull

PlatformsWindows

Action

Adventure

Casual

AI Review Summary

The Wolf Among Us is a masterclass in narrative-driven gaming that blends gritty noir detective tropes with a unique reimagining of fairy tale characters in a modern setting. While the storytelling and atmosphere are widely hailed as peak Telltale, some players find the illusion of choice and the short overall length to be significant drawbacks.

Pros

Exceptional world-building and writing that successfully translates fairy tale lore into a hard-boiled detective story.95%
Strong character development and high-quality voice acting that create a compelling, mature atmosphere.90%
Distinctive and stylish comic-book-inspired art direction that remains visually impressive years after release.85%
Engaging mystery plot that maintains tension and interest across its episodic structure.80%

Cons

The 'illusion of choice' is easily dispelled on repeat playthroughs, as many decisions lead to the same outcomes.80%
The game is relatively short, with some players completing the entire story in under 10 hours.75%
The ending can feel rushed or leave certain narrative threads unsatisfactorily resolved.60%
Technical glitches occasionally interfere with critical dialogue choices or gameplay sequences.40%

Notable Mentions

Frequently cited as Telltale Games' best work, often compared favorably to The Walking Dead.
The game is highly recommended for non-gamers due to its accessible, story-rich nature.
The first half of the first episode is noted by some to be slower than the rest of the experience.

Confidence: 53%

Based on the 156 most relevant reviewsGenerated on Aug 15, 2026

Game Vitals

Live snapshot

Player Activity

Current peak

176

Peak · last 90 days

652

All-time peak

14.1K

Price

Current price

$14.99

Lowest tracked

$5.99since Jan 5, 2026

Review Sentiment

Launch week

—

Last 30 days

96%

All-time positive

98%

Review Statistics

Total Reviews40.2K

Positive: 39.3K (98%)Negative: 853 (2%)

Reviews from Steam Deck

Dev Response Rate

15h

Avg Playtime at Review

95%

Credible Reviews