GamerVerdict

Powered by GameTrail.io

All Reviews·About·Privacy Policy·Terms·

© 2026 GamerVerdict. All rights reserved.

Contact us at support@gamerverdict.com

GamerVerdict is not affiliated with Valve Corporation. Steam and the Steam logo are trademarks of Valve Corporation.

We Were Here Forever

We Were Here Forever

You both awaken imprisoned inside the sinister Castle Rock - were you betrayed, or simply not that clever? Find out in the greatest co-op puzzle adventure in the We Were Here Series! Do you and your partner have what it takes to face the dark forces of this realm or will you be trapped… forever?

90%
Very Positive
DeveloperTotal Mayhem Games
PublisherTotal Mayhem Games
Release DateMay 10, 2022
$17.99
Peak Players8.4K
PlatformsWindows
Adventure
Casual
Indie
AI Review Summary

We Were Here Forever is widely considered the most ambitious and polished entry in the series, offering significantly more content and more creative puzzles than its predecessors. While it delivers a highly satisfying cooperative experience and deep lore, some players find certain late-game mechanics and strict timers frustratingly difficult or poorly explained.

Pros

  • Significant improvement over previous installments in terms of scope, quality, and puzzle variety.90%
  • Creative and diverse puzzle design that feels purposeful and satisfying to solve.90%
  • Strong cooperative gameplay that encourages communication and creates memorable shared moments.80%
  • Substantial amount of content, reportedly doubling the playtime of the previous title.70%
  • Engaging lore and a fantastic, emotionally resonant ending that ties the series together.60%

Cons

  • Frustrating time-based mechanics in the final puzzle can feel unfair or tedious.70%
  • Occasional lack of clarity in puzzle objectives leads to players guessing what the game wants.60%
  • Technical bugs and performance issues can occasionally disrupt the experience.50%
  • High difficulty spikes and convoluted mechanics can cause significant stress between partners.40%

Notable Mentions

  • Reviewers highlight that the game contains roughly twice as much content as We Were Here Together.
  • The ending is noted for its emotional weight and impact on the player relationship.
Confidence: 62%
Based on the 97 most relevant reviewsGenerated on Sep 18, 2026
Game Vitals

Live snapshot

Player Activity

Current peak
348
Peak · last 90 days
860
All-time peak
8.4K

Price

Current price
$17.99
Lowest tracked
$6.83since Jan 19, 2026

Review Sentiment

Last 30 days
88%
All-time positive
90%
Review Statistics
Total Reviews19.0K
Positive: 17.2K (90%)Negative: 1.8K (10%)

2%

Reviews from Steam Deck

4%

Dev Response Rate

13h

Avg Playtime at Review

93%

Credible Reviews