What are the pros of Melvor Idle?

Faithfully captures the essence of RuneScape mechanics in a streamlined, idle format.. Exceptional depth and complexity for an idle game, offering hundreds of hours of progression.. Perfect for background play while working or multitasking.. Strong value proposition with meaningful DLC that expands the base game significantly.. Highly addictive gameplay loop that integrates well into daily routines..

What are the cons of Melvor Idle?

Requires an active server connection to play a primarily single-player experience.. Persistent reports of local and cloud save data being lost or deleted.. Recent updates to the Township skill have been poorly received, with players citing increased friction and reduced utility.. Combat progression can feel significantly more frustrating and grindy than non-combat skills.. Occasional server outages can prevent players from accessing their saves entirely..

Melvor Idle

Inspired by RuneScape, Melvor Idle takes the core of what makes an adventure game so addictive and strips it down to its purest form! This is a feature-rich, idle/incremental game combining a distinctly familiar feel with a fresh gameplay experience. Maxing 20+ skills has never been more zen.

90%

Very Positive

DeveloperGames by Malcs

PublisherJagex Ltd

Release DateNov 18, 2021

$9.99

Peak Players11.8K

PlatformsWindows · macOS · Linux

AI Review Summary

Melvor Idle is a deep, menu-driven RPG that successfully distills the progression loops of RuneScape into a highly addictive idle experience. It is widely praised for its depth and suitability as a background task, though recent technical issues and controversial balance updates have sparked criticism.

Pros

Faithfully captures the essence of RuneScape mechanics in a streamlined, idle format.95%
Exceptional depth and complexity for an idle game, offering hundreds of hours of progression.90%
Perfect for background play while working or multitasking.85%
Strong value proposition with meaningful DLC that expands the base game significantly.75%
Highly addictive gameplay loop that integrates well into daily routines.80%

Cons

Requires an active server connection to play a primarily single-player experience.85%
Persistent reports of local and cloud save data being lost or deleted.75%
Recent updates to the Township skill have been poorly received, with players citing increased friction and reduced utility.80%
Combat progression can feel significantly more frustrating and grindy than non-combat skills.65%
Occasional server outages can prevent players from accessing their saves entirely.70%

Notable Mentions

Reviewers frequently describe the game as a 'spreadsheet simulator' due to its UI-heavy design.
A free browser version exists, which many users recommend trying before purchasing the Steam version.
The game has a very high retention rate, with an average playtime exceeding 900 hours among reviewers.

Confidence: 73%

Based on the 200 most relevant reviewsGenerated on Sep 29, 2026

Game Vitals

Live snapshot

Player Activity

Current peak

4.1K

Peak · last 90 days

5.7K

All-time peak

11.8K

Price

Current price

$9.99

Lowest tracked

$3.99since Aug 17, 2026

Review Sentiment

Launch week

100%

Last 30 days

86%

All-time positive

90%

Review Statistics

Total Reviews16.3K

Positive: 14.7K (90%)Negative: 1.6K (10%)

Reviews from Steam Deck

Dev Response Rate

966h

Avg Playtime at Review

87%

Credible Reviews